ORIGINAL SOURCE CONTENT · FDB-0025

BATCH1_HANDOVER_REPORT.md

The text below is original source material, not a translated website interface or empirical validation claim.

SHA-256 ace7f7913fc086439550a6fc513b7aed0c044e88d80912fea9d71982497fb389

# BATCH 1 R1 — Phase Lifecycle & Authority Governance Handover

## Dependency
Batch1 R1 continues to use the frozen Batch0 audit baseline by reference only:

- `PICKLEBALL_DATABASE_BATCH0_AUDIT_HANDOVER_R2.zip`
- SHA-256: `1c775412663cf23bcb4f4fd44e607c17776a9ccaa600ef74195fccd082ce6491`
- Embedded in Batch1 R1 ZIP: **NO**

Batch0 files were not modified. Source Phase1–20E / GEO-AEO v19 records were not modified. No external research was performed. Batch2 was not started.

## R1 correction summary
- Phase11 Batch01 remains `AUTHORITATIVE_FROZEN`; no lifecycle demotion or promotion was made.
- Failed audit `ART-E35B00D2EC33D2D0` is preserved as `HISTORICAL_REFERENCE` with `audit_verdict = REPAIR_REQUIRED` and is excluded from positive authority.
- Final audit `ART-ECBF9B0C2CD91D71` is the valid positive evidence for Batch01 acceptance/freeze because it verifies the exact Batch01 SHA as `EXACT MATCH TO ACCEPTED BASELINE` and explicitly records Batch01 as `FROZEN`.
- `SEV-00060` now cites the valid final audit; `SEV-00061` uses reviewer type `INDEPENDENT_AUDITOR`.
- `audit_verdict` and evidence-role separation were added to prevent independent-audit artifact type from being mistaken for a positive verdict.
- Historical failure chain is preserved through `SEV-00103` rather than erased.
- New QA `NO_NEGATIVE_AUDIT_USED_AS_POSITIVE_AUTHORITY` passes with zero positive-authority violations.

## Preserved governance conclusions
- Phase1–11 accepted/frozen conclusions remain unchanged.
- Phase10 DRAFT filename remains subordinate to Level A/B exact authority evidence.
- Phase11 semantic boundary `INDUSTRY_GEOMETRY_ARCHETYPE != FACTORY_OWNED_MOLD` remains unchanged.
- Phase12–20E remain current candidates with independent acceptance/freeze not confirmed.
- Phase12 supersession ambiguity remains unresolved rather than guessed.
- GEO/AAO v19 remains `DEPRECATED_LEGACY` / `LEGACY_ONLY`.
- No upstream ZIP nesting is introduced.

## Handover statistics
- Governed phases/subphases/work packages/revisions: **30**
- Governed artifact identities: **62**
- Authoritative frozen artifact identities: **9**
- Current candidate artifact identities: **17**
- Superseded artifact identities: **0**
- Deprecated/legacy artifact identities: **2**
- Unresolved governance exceptions: **20**
- Confirmed artifact relationship rows: **9**
- Unresolved/unconfirmed artifact relationship rows: **3**
- Status events: **103**
- Known independent audit records classified: **6**
- Negative audit records: **1**
- Negative audits used as positive authority after R1: **0**
- QA PASS: **20**
- QA REVIEW: **1**
- QA FAIL: **0**

## Remaining known limitations
1. Phase1–9 accepted/frozen lifecycle is established by governance records, but exact earlier accepted package byte identities/hashes are not fully present in the current master package; the existing QA REVIEW remains a traceability limitation, not a demotion.
2. Phase12–20E still require independent review before any promotion.
3. Phase12 bridge/OEM family replacement scope remains unresolved.
4. R1 did not reopen unrelated Batch1 findings or run a new full Batch1 audit.

## Stop condition
Batch1 R1 deliverables are complete. Batch2 has not been started.

**STATUS: READY FOR INDEPENDENT RE-AUDIT**